Baylor Line is supported by our sponsors! Become one today.

Did the Infamous White House Plumber Attend Baylor?: James W. McCord and Me

Robert F. Darden uncovers if Watergate burglar James McCord ever attended Baylor, recounting his own story as a young journalist along the way.

•

Jonathon Platt, CEO of The Baylor Line, claims that there is only a degree or two of separation between Baylor University and just about any other story, event, or person you can imagine.

I’ve always agreed. 

And that was before I found an unlikely connection with convicted Watergate conspirator James W. McCord.

Let me explain.

Readers of a certain age will remember that McCord was one of the five men arrested and later convicted in the botched burglary of the offices of the Democratic Party’s national offices in the now infamous Watergate Hotel in Washington, D.C. 

While not as well-known as G. Gordon Liddy or E. Howard Hunt, McCord’s conviction and later admission of guilt implicating the Committee to Re-Elect the President (known by the unfortunate acronym CREEP) ultimately led to the resignation of President Richard Nixon.

When I arrived at Baylor August 1972, I was already a voracious consumer of newspapers — sports coverage of the St. Louis Cardinals, editorial cartoons by the likes of Bill Mauldin and Herblock, and the comics section (particularly Pogo) — had been my gateway drug into print journalism. I had originally wanted to be an editorial cartoonist myself.

By Spring 1973, coverage of the bungled Watergate break-in regularly crowded the war in Vietnam, the draft, and civil rights demonstrations off the front pages of America’s newspapers, including The Lariat. 

Read more: How the growing national Watergate friction fueled the backdrop for Jesse Jackson’s 1973 visit to Waco

At the time, there was a persistent rumor on campus that James W. McCord had attended Baylor. This despite the fact that when asked directly about McCord, Registrar James Berryhill told The Lariat on May 1, 1973, that his office had “no record of his attendance.” 

But this is one of those urban legends that refuses to die — even McCord’s Wikipedia entry still mentions that he was (however briefly) a Baylor Bear before graduating from the University of Texas with a BBA in 1949.


Encouraged by friends from Woodville’s Kirby High School (where I managed to finish 25th in a class of 88) already at Baylor, I took classes in journalism with legendary professors David McHam, Harry Marsh, and Michael Stricklin. By the end of the Introduction to Journalism class with McHam, I was hooked.

And as a lowly slime cap-wearing freshman, I desperately wanted to write and draw for The Lariat. But the student newspaper was absolutely loaded with talented writers, most of whom would go on to long, distinguished careers — Paul Parsons, Kay Brown, John Rutledge, David Pickle, Kiki Dreyer, Marvin Hogan, Libby Vandervort, Rick Hale, Marsha Comstock, Beverly Narum, and others. Outside of maybe Ken Askew and the late Rick Bradfield, freshmen like me never really had a chance.

Fortunately, I could draw. And when it came to Watergate, I had actually been there!

During the summers of 1972 and ‘73, while living in Alexandria, Virginia (my father was assigned to the Office of the Air Force Inspector General in the Pentagon), and by virtue of an unexpectedly good Civil Service Exam score, I had received a much-coveted (in my mind, at least) position working in the art and photography department in the basement of the State Department in Washington, D.C. I commuted from Alexandria on Route 1 each day with a friend from church.

At least once a week that summer, I took my brown bag lunch, walked across Foggy Bottom to the Russell Senate Office Building — specifically to the Senate caucus room — where the Senate Watergate Committee hearings were held and where the imperious Sen. Sam Ervin presided. (Imagine! In those days, spectators could just waltz right into a Washington, D.C. office building!) 

I don’t remember seeing McCord specifically, but a helpful Senate page pointed out Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein! 

I was mesmerized by the proceedings.

As Baylor’s spring ’73 semester drew to a close, I gathered my courage and timidly approached The Lariat editors with a pen and ink sketch I had laboriously drawn of a secret agent-looking guy listening to a wiretap. The “wire” in the wiretap was composed of the names of the principals in the Watergate investigation and hearings — including McCord’s. Thankfully, the editors liked the illustration and published it on the front page of the May 1, 1973, edition of The Lariat.

I still have a faded copy. It was one of the pivotal moments of my life. I knew I was going into journalism.

The front page of The Lariat on May 1, 1973, features Darden’s artwork. | Courtesy of The Lariat

It was McCord, you may remember, who struck the final blow against the Nixon administration’s rapidly crumbling defense. In March, McCord sent a letter to Judge John J. Sirica, who read it aloud in the courtroom. In the letter, McCord claimed that he feared for his life and the lives of his family and that he and his fellow burglars had been under “political pressure to plead guilty and remain silent, that perjury had been committed at the trial, and that higher-ups had approved the Watergate operations.”

Of McCord’s disclosures, Sirica later wrote in The New York Times, “The trickle of information he provided soon became a flood no plumber could stop.”

The hearings, investigations, denials, and delays continued for another year, culminating with the House Judiciary Committee impeachment hearings, which ran from July 24-30, 1974. I avidly consumed it all in The Lariat and The Washington Post.

On Friday, August 9, 1974, my father and I sat glued to the television as Nixon announced his resignation. My father, Col. Robert F. Darden Jr., was an imposing 6’4”, ramrod-straight former B-52 pilot, an Air Force lifer, and a passionate, conservative Republican. Not surprisingly, we rarely agreed on anything — including my long hair and drum set — and our relationship was often fraught and tense.

Darden plays the drums in the orchestra pit of Waco Hall in 1973. | Courtesy of Robert F. Darden

When Nixon walked to the helicopter waiting on the White House grounds and waved goodbye, my father turned to me and with angry tears snarled, “I hope you’re proud of yourself. You did this. You and your newspapers.”

I did this? My newspapers?

Holey moley! I was just a sophomore journalism major at Baylor University, still struggling to get printed in The Lariat. 

But I knew even then I was part of something bigger. It was a sea change moment in my life.


Back to McCord.

There is a library of books on Watergate. The Baylor and Waco/McLennan County libraries have dozens upon dozens of them and for this story, I skimmed through as many as I could find for any information on James W. McCord and his alleged attendance at Baylor and found nothing.

I fruitlessly poured through issues of The Lariat and The Round Up from the 1940s.

Baylor, of course, does have a concrete Watergate connection — famed prosecutor Leon Jaworski is a Baylor graduate and The Texas Collection has a complete set of the voluminous Watergate files. 

Additionally, the W. R. Poage Library’s political collection includes uncounted newspapers, magazines, pamphlets, newsletters, audio recordings, books, and posters related to Watergate — many devoted to the thousands of conspiracies related to the whole sordid affair. The shadowy McCord — who claimed to have worked for both the FBI and CIA — shows up repeatedly. 

But I found nothing about his personal life beyond that. Nada.

The only detailed biographical information comes from Bernstein and Woodward’s definitive All the President’s Men, published in 1974 (and later made into a brilliant movie with Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman). After the break-in was reported, the two reporters from The Washington Post immediately dove into McCord’s past. By interviewing people who knew McCord, particularly in his hometown of suburban Rockville, Maryland, Woodward built the only significant profile of this notoriously private man:

… a native of the Texas Panhandle; deeply religious, active in the First Baptist Church of Washington; father of an Air Force Academy cadet, and a [mentally challenged] daughter; an ex-FBI agent; military reservist; former chief of physical security for the CIA; teacher of a security course at Montgomery Junior College; family man; extremely conscientious; quiet; reliable.

That’s it. 

And nothing about Baylor.


Though originally sentenced to five years in prison for his part in the affair, McCord only served four months at a minimum-security federal prison in Allenwood, Pennsylvania. After his release, he returned home, stayed out of the spotlight, resumed his security consulting business, and eventually disappeared from the public eye.

Also in 1974, McCord self-published a now long out-of-print book titled A Piece of Tape: The Watergate Story – Fact and Fiction, which Baylor’s InterLibrary Loan miraculously found for me. But it too contains absolutely no personal information. We can glean a little from the acknowledgements, which include thanks to his family and friends; members of the media “who I respect for their integrity of reporting,” namely Bob Jackson of The Los Angeles Times; and a few others. 

It concludes with a single sentence: “My decision to participate in the Watergate operation was a mistake. That the Almighty worked through the wrong that was Watergate, and is continuing to do so, for His own purposes and in ways man cannot fully comprehend, I have not the slightest doubt.”

Again, no mention of Baylor.

That McCord disappeared so completely despite the public’s continuing obsession with Watergate is a tribute to his expertise in security. In fact, although McCord died on June 15, 2017, at his home in Douglassville, Pennsylvania, at the age 93, his death was not reported either locally or nationally for another two years. 

McCord’s belated New York Times obituary added that the “sturdy, balding man with hollow cheeks and a military bearing” had been born in Waurika, Oklahoma, on January 26, 1924, grew up in Texas, may have participated in the Bay of Pigs fiasco with the CIA, and that he and his wife Sarah had three children, not two.

But nothing about Baylor.

So how and when did the rumor of McCord’s attending Baylor come about? 

In that same May 1, 1973, issue, The Lariat notes that Attorney General Richard Kleindienst, the “law-and-order” man brought in by the Nixon administration to “clean up the mess” but who resigned shortly thereafter for “unclear reasons,” had actually been the featured speaker at the Baylor Law School awards banquet a month earlier.

Also worth mentioning, in the late 1960s, the president of Princeton Theological Seminary, Dr. James McCord, had spoken at Baylor on more than one occasion.

Perhaps the two things got conflated?

But in the end, an urban legend doesn’t need to be accurate — it only needs to be repeated.


McCord’s name — and infamy — live on. In May 2023, HBO released a multi-part fictionalized account of the Watergate break-in titled The White House Plumbers, starring Woody Harrelson as E. Howard Hunt, Justin Theroux as G. Gordon Liddy, and Toby Huss as McCord.

More importantly, despite the ferocious attacks on journalism in recent years, the investigative journalism of Woodward and Bernstein continues. Recent movies like Spotlight (The Boston Globe’s investigation of predator priests) and She Said (the courageous female reporters who exposed Harvey Weinstein) are just the spear tip of a host of crucial investigations ongoing every day in the most inhospitable political and social climate imaginable.


So, in the end, I can’t find any proof that James W. McCord actually attended Baylor, though it makes me smile to think that if he did, I might have actually sat in one of the same seats he occupied in an English or history class.

But it was Watergate that was one of the true sparks that led to a long, rewarding career, first as a working journalist, then decades teaching young reporters at Baylor.

In class, I faithfully told my students the same things that McHam, Marsh, and Stricklin told me during the heady days of Watergate back in the early 1970s: that journalism is a tough, thankless profession. That the Committee to Protect Journalists reports that 128 journalists died covering stories in 2025, including at least 50 targeted killings, and that’s in addition to the hundreds who were wounded or are imprisoned. And so far in 2026, 27 reporters have died, most in Lebanon and the Gaza Strip.

Today there are fewer newspapers, more restrictions, more attacks from government officials, and less support and respect from the citizens, institutions and governments that journalists are desperately trying to protect by shining a light in dark places.

Read more: What the Baylor Religion Survey reveals about Americans’ distrust in today’s journalism

And yet right up until the final journalism class I taught at Baylor in May 2023, I had incredibly bright, talented, courageous young men and women who wanted to become reporters and make a difference in the world.


One of my all-time favorite movies, of course, is All the President’s Men. Like Field of Dreams, it always makes me cry. But the film about journalism that I quote the most is an obscure black-and-white crime drama from 1952, written and directed by Richard Brooks, Deadline – USA, starring Humphrey Bogart. Bogie plays the editor of a tough little urban newspaper, The Day, that’s about to close under financial pressure from a showier competitor. Even in its final hours, the dedicated editors, photographers, and reporters at The Day are working on a dangerous exposé of a murderous crime boss in the city.

In the film, a young journalism school graduate shows up and asks for a job, even if it is just for a few days. Bogie grimaces, and then says, “About this wanting to be a reporter, don’t ever change your mind. It may not be the oldest profession, but it’s the best.”


James W. McCord may not have attended Baylor, but his participation in one of the greatest journalism triumphs of the modern age unwittingly influenced thousands of reporters, young and old, and thousands more would-be reporters like me who listened in wide-eyed wonder to real-life heroes like McHam, Marsh, and Stricklin … and who convinced us that the unimaginable was an ink-stained possibility.

Latest from Baylor Line

Under the Guardian Cap

On November 30, 2025, Baylor graduate and Houston Texans defensive back Jalen Pitre returned to the field after a three-week,

Recommended

What I Did On My Summer Vacation

On visits to Chicago when she was growing up, Dr. Saralyn McKinnon-Crowley watched Jeopardy! with her grandmother. Even then, she

The Noticer

Greg Davis (‘92) thinks there’s a meaningful moment of time between when you wake up and when you’re actually awake.

Who’s Minding The Store?

As the October 1, 2025, federal government shutdown stretched from days to weeks, one consequence was the disruption of Supplemental

Live Entertainment Comes to Baylor

In 1996 the average price for concert tickets was around $25. Today it’s about $130. Talk about sticker shock. Surge